in contrast to the american revolution the french revolution

Shes there to fire up the the far right wingers. Its coming up on eight years since, now. So let me just hit you with a smattering of what we hear. However, at the same time, and I actually wanna write about this, I think a lot of the folks who are saying, well, look, I mean, weve got blue cities and red states and got red areas and blue states. Lets listen. Our editors will review what youve submitted and determine whether to revise the article. After French King Louis XVI was tried and executed on January 21, 1793, war between France and monarchal nations Great Britain and Spain was inevitable. The nation of Haiti formally declared its independence on January 1, 1804. Shes never been conservative about anything. And then it runs in to the new course of the river. they think they should take, and thats a compromise to them. On July 14th, the Parisians responded by storming the royal prison, called the Bastille. Why are we talking about it so much? I used to respect you. And the identity is, well, Im a Republican. Both of the revolutions were liberating, but the French revolution was more violent and bloodier than the American. We know a lot about that. Both countries have many differences and similarities, ranging from the individuals fighting these wars to tactics and strategies they used to win. The American and French Revolution are not duplicates of each other, but they are very similar. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices. Hello. It was a period of time when the people overthrow the government and took over to create a better leadership for the country. And so thats why, you know, when I think about National Unity going forward, that exhausted majority So long as the operative word is exhausted and not majority, we face a problem. To change the laws, the king called a representative body known as the Estates General in 1788. Thats right. Mhmm. Although the American and French revolutions were very similar in the actions, there were many differences leading them into ultimately different paths and states of rest. So long as their politicians remain Republican compared to the Democratic Party, which is just not an for them, period end discussion, no further conversation necessary. And, you know, one of the powers you wanna go back to our founding documents, for example, the statement that all men are created equal and endowed by their creator certain unalienable rights among them, life liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, was setting a cultural course for the United States that we were often contrary to, but had enormous power over the course of the next two centuries plus to where eventually we started to get more and more and more in conformity with that vision. Yeah. They get in and then they start calling the other people names. Oh, no. Okay. The terms of Continental Army service were only gradually increased from one to three years, and not even bounties and the offer of land kept the army up to strength. How did Enlightenment ideas, including ideas about sovereignty, contribute to the Atlantic Revolutions? During the Second Continental Congress in 1776, the representatives adopted the Declaration of Independence on July 4. The total number of the former provided by quotas from the states throughout the conflict was 231,771 men, and the militias totaled 164,087. Or if youre a typical Democrat, you believe that the average Republican is a lot more extreme than they are. So some of it is this social signaling. And then became socialized differently through the course of Donald Trump. Everyone, and welcome to the Focus Group podcast. The thesis of the book is really stated in the first sentence of the book, which is that there isnt any truly national, cultural, religious, social, political trend that is pulling us together more than its pushing us apart. David, my friend, thank you for being here. And its very difficult to go against that. Yeah. The National Assembly ended the privileges of the nobles and ended feudalism in France. Students complete an 11 item graphic organizer with 3 questions to compare and contrast the Revolutionary War and French Revolution. Dont say it. In response, several men from Boston dressed up as Indigenous Americans and threw tea from British ships into Boston harbor. Im Sarah Longwell, Publisher of The Bulwark. Shortly after that, in the 1700s there was the French Revolution. And this is happening not just in the sense of you and your neighbor being pushed apart. And if you look at the constitution, The bill of rights and the civil war amendments together are this big one two punch that says, here are all of the baseline rights that we have, human rights that we possess, as Americans that we all possess, and that cannot be taken away by losing an election. This document declared the sovereignty of the American states and listed the natural rights of mankind. Two of the main revolutions were the French Revolution and the Latin American Revolution. But the point is that I would love to live in a bread state. So thanks to all of you for joining us for another episode of the Focus Group. And in fact, If youre a typical Republican, you think the average Democrat is a lot more extreme than they are. By contrast, the British army was a reliable steady force of professionals. Since it numbered only about 42,000, heavy recruiting programs were introduced. My favorite example of that, Sarah, I was volunteering for Samaritans person Mayfield, Kentucky after these terrible tornadoes. All revolutions have many stages which they go through, these three stages are the main bits of a, The American Revolution and the French Revolution have similar and different causes to their revolution. Thats like, old stuff. Kristen Soltis Anderson, I believe, And, Kristen, Im sorry, Im misattributing this to you, but I remember hearing an interview where youre talking about polling Republicans and how important the person at the top of the ticket is to Republican views on issue after issue after issue. Shes not their cup of tea. Many states continued to combine church and state. Oh, if Democrats move into red states, they shouldnt be able to vote for at least five years. And thats a thats a Dominion voting system. Both of the revolutions were liberating, but the French revolution was more violent and bloodier than the American. France was defeated, humiliated, and in even more debt than the British. And how . When did the most disturbing pieces of data I have seen in the last really since Trump came down the escalator, which is I mean, Sarah, think about it. I do not like them. Youve seen the GIF of Homer Simpson with his eyes wide kind of backing into the shrubbery. For example, during the late 1700s, the French Revolution began to occur for that reason. Is the way that they perceive Marjorie De La Grida is having sort of like a legitimate role in the coalition. The American and French revolutions are similar in some ways but different in others. It was a bloody battle between the Mexican people and people who were loyal to Spain. They then read, analyze, and compare and contrast each country's national anthem, the Star Spangled Banner and La Marseillaise, by answering 14 questions of varying degrees of difficulty. So this is my last question for you. The goal of the American Revolution was to get away from the British government and be free. because a lot of right wing media is an audition for Fox News. Similarly, in early 1775, colonists were preparing for revolution against a power that they felt oppressed their rights and wanted to take away their liberties. Can you imagine a United States of Latin America? mean, when did Chris Ruffo become a traitor to the cause? You know, the majority of people in Scotland voted to stay. Several men in uniform clap as another is presented with an award. What were the major causes of the American Revolution? I mean, I guess you kinda need somebody like that on the team too, but you dont really put anything into it. In 1810, peasants in Mexico revolted because they wanted their own land and because food prices were too high. One of the things I fear about the right is the cultural course of the river that is being said. Shes not serious. Right? John Locke, Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Denis Diderot, and Baron de Montesquieu were all part of the Enlightenment. One hundred percent. The Haitian Revolution was the most radical. They both seem to have common results but the results are definitely different when it comes to how it affected their countries. energy to do the real logistical Bulwark. its not an insignificant part of the party. Large billows of smoke blow into the sky. And then heres the other problem, Sarah Longwell can point to scandals, you know, in mainstream or left wing media, and that are real that happened and are bad. No. But then if you tell them about, say, the Seth Rich conspiracy theory coming out of Fox or all of the Dominion nonsense coming out of Fox, that doesnt tell them to distrust Fox. I would say that the actual number of people who really truly want a national divorce is very small, relatively small. These people arent advocating. During the French Revolution, there was a period known as the Reign of terror which was a period of extreme violence and brutality against people who did not support the French Revolution. Throughout history there have been many wars and revolutions. And so And Federalist Ten, what James Madison does is he talks about expanding the sphere of the American Republic. And its so hard to know where the truth is. Thats right. right now. Dont take that seriously. Furthermore, according to recent surveys by Israeli media outlets KAN and N12, only 24-28% of the general electorate are in favor of this revolution. All the peasants wanted to be free of the unfair taxation on items such as tea and stamps considering they had no say. Im the toughest right winger in the room kind of thing. Now, I just wanna stress again. Theyre passive participants and commentators about events that theyre not in control of that theyre not gonna exert their will over one way or the other. Overview: In this lesson, students will analyze primary and secondary sources using the OPTIC strategy. thanks so much for having me. So theyre like, this is stupid. The French justified their revolution by following the same principles as the colonists did. In the early stages of the rebellion by the American colonists, most of them still saw themselves as English subjects who were being denied their rights as such. I mean, which okay? In the American colonies there was no set divisions of people and power, all social classes were equally affected by the government. How effective they can be? And so the direction that the river flows, whether its towards integrity, whether its towards compassion, etcetera, or whether its towards division, or towards anger, Its not that you cant defy the leader, but its exhausting and hard because youre swimming upstream. Theres just no question about that. I thought that. But like for the most part, they were decent people who recognized, like, that Trump is bad. Divided We Fall: Americas Secession Threat and How to Restore Our Nation (by David French), https://www.nytimes.com/2023/02/26/opinion/fox-news-lies-dominion.html, Learn more about your ad choices. And, you know, one of the things thats distressing is that this idea that, well, we know theres stream. Several horses and men are down. Look, thats an unhealthy instinct in a democratic policy. So she has a role to play in the coalition. He joins Sarah to talk about whether (and how) the United States holds together; and the task of rebuilding trust in our institutions. You know, get out the first and you wont be the last person to accuse me of polyamish thinking about people. And so thats sort of this core vision of pluralism. And if you look across the world, youll see, for example, the United Kingdom, came very close to its own separation with the Scottish referendum. I mean, she definitely appeals to that super far right group and guests who have a coach for him, Georgia. Taxation without representation was when the government taxed the colonies without. Everywhere the French went, they ended feudalism, promoted equal rights and religious tolerance, and modernized government administrations. Mhmm. I often talk about the Republican triangle of doom, which is the toxic and symbiotic relationship between the right wing infotainment media, politicians, and the voters that it, like, increasingly radicalizes them. Yeah. What made the American Revolution look most like a civil war, though, was the reality that about one-third of the colonists, known as loyalists (or Tories), continued to support and fought on the side of the crown. Right? The French, Haitian, and American Revolutions were all sparked from the minds of the colonists, slaves, or lower classes who were treated with inequality by their own governments. Although the Civil War and American Revolution shared many similarities, the Civil War differed in the fact that it was more of a confrontation of two opposing. That cannot be taken away by living as a red minority in a blue state or a blue minority in a red state. it. In other words, the way that you deal with the dissent and debate in profound disagreements in what he calls like the danger or the violence of faction is not by trying to suppress factions. And they would have been part of that old coalition, and theyre different now. Its their input. and they love their kids and their grandkids. The french wanted reform and sovereignty from the french monarchy, they wanted a new leader and a new ruler. Saying how wrong now. All Rights Reserved. Thats doctor Seuss. The American revolution and the French Revolution are two major incidents happened in the 1700s, which had intense social impacts on both French and American societies. And the answer is the one you feed. Since you wrote the book. With fear and famine, French peasants arrived outside the Bastille demanding weaponry and getting denied. When it comes to the outcomes of each it seems as if the French Revolution created more change than the English Civil War did. No matter their credentials. Because its like state run media, like what they have in China. An MTG isnt the only high profile figure to raise the prospect of secession, national divorce and civil war over the past few years. A revolution is a movement that people do for a change in the government because reasons, such as equality rights. How did they differ? Yeah. Their idea of a compromise is well take only half of what we think we should take. The American Revolution against the British during 1775 to 1783 and the French Revolution against their own, French government during 1789 to 1799 were both one of the most important political and social turnovers in the world. But how interested are Americans really and breaking up? And And I said, well, how was your voting experience? To conduct investigation. Back across the Atlantic Ocean, the people of the French colony of Saint Domingue (now Haiti) on the island of Hispaniola were watching the French Revolution very closely. And this week, were talking about the prospect of a national divorce. I live in Tennessee. Sort of laughing at the excesses and not taking it incredibly seriously. Militias, poorly disciplined and with elected officers, were summoned for periods usually not exceeding three months. This is a group that dislikes Donald Trump, wants to move on to Ron DeSantis. And after January sixth, Trumps approval rating with Republicans stayed very high, very slight downslope, very slight. Theyre not taking all of what. What the leader does is the leader sets the course of a cultural river. Their eyes are wide. But the idea that between the two people on January sixth, Trump, who wanted to overturn the election in Pence, who had stood by Trump every second of the four years prior, and who drew the line at a coup was going to then lose his standing and become a what happened to Mike Pences situation. 4.6. mean, but we know were trending with violence. Compare And Contrast The American Revolution And French Revolution. Two priestsMiguel Hidalgo and Jos Morelosled the insurrection, but it was eventually put down by wealthy Creole landowners with the support of the Catholic Church. So number one, Al Yuval Levin has said this very well that theres a George Wallace constituency in American politics. Though the Third Estate represented many more people and had twice the number of delegates, each estate had an equal vote. Lets listen. And Pence and McConnell who opposed Trumps attempt to overturn the election, their approval rating dropped to such an extent that Mike Pence now who may well run for president is widely viewed as having no standing, no meaningful standing. Its pretty much like in good faith But because theyre pouring Fox News and the daily wire and other right wing sources into their ears, they dont have that much context, and they do think that Fox is the most trustworthy, and its all the other people who are wrong, look, people are responsible for their own actions, responsible for things, but they Im most had been poisoned slowly by these institutions. And does it not strike anybody strange that you go to four different media houses and theyre all saying the same thing. Most men are on horseback, fighting with swords. Their society was split into two groups. And so when you talk to somebody who liked those folks in the focus group, Its like peeling an onion of manufactured distrust. Right? Intentionally lying. Let let Kelly sit. Right? Thats what she spends all her time doing, and she knits them sweaters and all that stuff. Revolutionary leaders established new countries that only sometimes lived up to promises of democratic rule. The French were under a monarchy so the only option they had was to overthrow their king a create a republic. Both The root cause: taxation without representation (American, French, or Both?) If the right wing media is your universe. the fox scandal they may have. I dont see so much national divorce rhetoric coming from the left. I mean, if youre talking about in the millions, yes, but as a percentage of Americans, low. Using the language of the Enlightenment, they initially tried to promote harmony between France's social classes and establish a constitutional monarchy with King Louis still on a throne. The Mexican Revolution for Independence lasted for 11 years from 1810-1821. King Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette lived in Versailles far from the other forms of government, abusing the country wealth. And because when Fox called Arizona, the response was not. So its been a a minority of it is now in which makes it far more powerful. In general, the American Revolution was more successful than the French revolution. His idea was the separation of powers so its balanced, as in what we still use. I LOVE THIS WOMAN WHO MAKES UP DR. SUS RISE ABOUT BEING VICTIMIZED. Malcolm F. Purinton is a part-time lecturer of world history and the history of modern Europe at Northeastern University and Emmanuel College in Boston. Revolutionaries were inspired by the ideals of the Enlightenment including individual freedom. Like, people you would want as neighbors. What were some other sources of the Haitian revolution? He specializes in the history of food and the environment, with a focus on beer and other alcoholic beverages. King Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette lived in Versailles far from the other forms of government, abusing the country wealth. The American and French revolutions are similar in some ways but different in others. Right. For Britain, taxing their American colonies seemed like a great idea, but after such a long time of self-rule and near autonomy, the colonists in North America had ideas of their own. And so if thats your news environment. To actively oppose it. Similar because of what caused both revolutions and different because of the violence that was used in each movement and the outcome from it. So I dont know. Omissions? British generals, however, tended toward a lack of imagination and initiative, while those who demonstrated such qualities often were rash. Thats all the good news. And and the question is is like, well, which one wins? So they finally recognized the independence of the 13 North American colonies in the 1783 Treaty of Paris. get to us? This is a great way to get students to think in depth and compare and contrast the American Revolution, French Revolution, and Russian Revolutions.The worksheet is sold separately and its called: World History: Comparing American, French, and Russian Revolutions This is an extension to another assignment that only compares the American and French Revolutions. I was listening to an interview, an oh, gosh. Divisions along racial, class, and ideological lines frequently led to violence. Youre literally not gonna know about one of the most consequential media scandals of my lifetime. But, like, we get out, man. They even briefly abolished slavery, which would have a strong effect in the French Caribbean colony of Saint Domingue. But in any event, so there are things that they said that I wasnt wild about. Yeah. It is a through line in the group. Because I Will Saletan is it is not a one-sided thing. We didnt include it because we have so much to get to on this, but, like, they went hundred percent. The French navy in particular played a key role in bringing about the British surrender at Yorktown, which effectively ended the war. Or is that just negative partisanship all the way down? In response, the British announced the Coercive (Intolerable) Acts in 1774, which closed Boston's harbor, curtailed local elections, and expanded the power of the royal governor. In general, the American Revolution was more successful than the French revolution. But I gotta tell you, when I was watching this group, I was reminded of something one of the things I get yelled at the most for online is whenever I say I really like a lot of the people that I listen to in the group. Good standing. However, there is a difference that makes the American revolution succeeded while the French revolution doesn't. It can happen. The new government seized and sold church lands. From 1790 to 1794, the French Revolution became increasingly radical. It warms its way in. It would be a very, very different party. Yeah. The French was in Europe fighting for freedom against its own government. Because these are the people who sort of know better, but theres no leader or anybody else who is appealing to the good nature thats inside of them that you hear coming out and is pulling on those best instincts to say we have to resist this. I like transparency and I like accountability. its what happened to you. The French Revolution was not successful in forming a democratic government due to France's history of a monarchy, economic issues and divison among its' people. American A "Reign of Terror" followed the revolution (American, French, or Both?) The Civil War was more than an unsatisfied party rebelling against a larger power, but a clash between two vastly different ways of life. Well, yes. They insisted on the implementation of new measures that would guarantee the natural rights of all citizens and believed that, as Rousseau wrote, no man has any natural authority over his fellow men, and since force is not the source of right, conventions remain as the basis of all lawful authority among men. . And so you can be a majority. And, like, ten seconds later, like, and its those stupid Democrats that wont, you know, get on board with whatever. The American Revolution took place between 1775 and 1783, while the French Revolution occurred between 1789 and 1799. And the leadership is this key element to how you bring out the better angels of our nature. And unsurprisingly, the next section I have here is, lets listen to these voters talk the media. Right? This is this is how things go. Even though it has a blue Nashville and a blue Memphis. Yes Ma'am Resources. Bolvar had the support of the relatively new nation of Haiti, and he visited that country twice. Three of their major results, In February 1861, a new government was on the horizon in the United States, known as the Confederate States of America. This is never gonna happen. Both revolutions were connected to each other because of the link between France and Haiti, known then as St Domingue. So yes, theres absolute social signaling where were in a competition and I see it more on the right. Britain did this primarily by imposing a series of deeply unpopular laws and taxes, including the Sugar Act (1764), the Stamp Act (1765), and the so-called Intolerable Acts (1774). This is all political. They had the same reason to revolt as the colonist did, they both felt like they were being oppressed, overtaxed and felt like they were. I was gonna say yes to both. We make this sphere of liberty bigger. A powerful and popular general named Napoleon Bonaparte soon rose to power and declared himself emperor in 1799. I mean, I live in California I wanna leave California. The government and leadership in France was corrupt as they were in much debt. Let us know if you have suggestions to improve this article (requires login). These countries shared the same idea of freedom and independence, the difference is they used different methods of accomplishing this goal. Kelly was right. And if you were going to go against that cultural tone on the right, it was exhausting. The politicians feed it. These ideas also shaped the American Revolution and the success of it went on to also inspire the French as, Though the American and French Revolution were similar in various ways they also had a key differences. Until early in 1778, the American Revolution was a civil war within the British Empire, but it became an international war as France (in 1778) and Spain (in 1779) joined the colonies against Britain. He joins Sarah to talk about whether (and how) the United States holds together; and the task of rebuilding trust in our institutions. You were just talking about it, about this latest thing with Fox News and what makes me so mad about that Fox News thing is and you hit this. Also the types of people who fought in the revolutions differed. Both the Creoles and the church were alarmed by the social radicalism of the revolt and worried that it would end like the French and Haitian revolutions. Americans were at first enthusiastic in support of the revolution. I dont get the sense from hearing that that theyre gonna actively oppose Marjorie Taylor. The colonists protested these heavy-handed taxes and rioted in the streets. And that was that. Right? Even with both Revolution developing years apart they had very similar desires and obstacles to face. How was the American Revolution a civil war? Two of the main revolutions were the French Revolution and the Latin American Revolution. Between 1775 and 1825, revolutions across the Americas and Europe changed the maps and governments of the Atlantic world. Theres no way all of this would happen or just a little too pollyanna ish, in my view, because if you go back to secession in eighteen sixty one, if you go back to the American revolution in seventeen seventy five, moving into seventeen seventy six, Much of the same stuff was true. Dont trust the FBI, but I wouldnt trust my own eyes. So I feel like Im in this kind of whirlwind of trying to fact find. PDF. I mean, its ridiculous the way its run right now. New York Times opinion columnist David French (literally) wrote the book on a possible national divorce. Yes. Just Its been built into the right through the cold war, through Romney telling Obama that Russia is our chief geopolitical foe. Whats the solution you get? And in fact, one of the things that sort of saved us from that group its not all been in one party. But at the same time, were not really gonna say this is way too far or were gonna exert any will to sort of purge this from the larger right wing coalition. When you think people are good people or youre a news organization, like your obligation is to tell them the truth and they knew the truth and they didnt tell it to people which means they hold them in contempt and they think theyre stupid. Denis Diderot also a French enlightenment thinker created an encyclopedia that explained the new ideas on the topics of government, philosophy, and religion. They also wanted to create a new government but king Louis XVI wouldnt sign it off so the National Assembly got mad and they overthrew the bastille. Because people do talk about the idea of national war, civil war, and just like how tense things are all the time. Shes wrong about everything. Weve most have been talking about the right. As to the American revolution was more conservative and federal. And Im talking to one of the most lovely people whos, you know, upped your eyeballs and debris trying to dig peoples possessions out of this catastrophe. And in fact, the dominion voting system that was the subject of an enormous amount of controversy, is a dramatic improvement over prior forms of voting. But what do you think? But a unified Latin America remained a dream only. Because then youre aiming straight at liberty. They voted for him twice though, then this to me, I find myself understanding these people and then also thinking that these are the most dangerous people. They write new content and verify and edit content received from contributors. A bloody, crowded battle scene shows Haitian revolutionaries fighting for their independence against European colonizers. In April of the following year, fighting began between British and American troops in Lexington and Concord in Massachusetts. It rejected European racist hierarchies and defined all Haitians as "black."